The Future of HANA Appliance Model with Increasing Adoption of TDI & Cloud Deployments

Appliance vs. Tailed Datacenter Integration (TDI)

In a non-HANA world, there is flexibility in choosing different hardware components from different sources and deploying them on dedicated or shared basis across applications. But HANA deployments have always been appliance based and a HANA appliance is a dedicated infrastructure with all components viz. storage, network, OS, DB, CPU & RAM delivered by an appliance vendor pre-configured as one bundle. Now SAP’s TDI model allows customers to build their own infrastructure set up for HANA deployments with H/W components from different sources.

Evolution of TDI

Since its inception five years ago, HANA for OLAP (BW, Data marts etc.) systems have come a long way and is now ready for various kinds of deployment viz. dedicated appliance; multi-tenancy model; private/public cloud hosted or TDI based installations. This is possible because of the data schema and the flexibility in data split/storage, which is different for OLAP (Transactional systems like ECC, CRM etc.) systems from OLTP systems.

However, in case of OLTP systems, it took a while for SAP to come up with a more inexpensive and affordable deployment model. In this model, SAP allows not only sharing the resources across applications but also allows use of existing resources. This will help customers to cut down on the initial CAPEX for their Suite on HANA implementations and migrations.

TDI has already been in existence for more than a year and is a proven model. With the public cloud providers rapidly moving to increased capacity, the number of appliance based HANA deployments is expected to be limited.

In addition to public cloud providers like Azure and AWS, most of the private cloud providers (close to 15 of them certified to provide HANA private cloud hosting) will rely on TDI model rather than a dedicated appliance model to achieve a lower TCO per customer.

Benefits of TDI

Preferred storage and network components
Choice of compute server processors
Pay per use models
Usage of existing hardware
No need for oversizing and huge initial investment for future requirements

Concerns or drawbacks?

One of the major drawbacks that we see with TDI option is a reasonably good investment that will be required for initial set up. However customers with a large SAP real estate or hosting providers with a large number of customers will recover this cost very quickly.

The others concerns/drawbacks are:

Limitation in the certified sizes for OLTP systems
Not proven yet for higher loads from performance perspective
Individual support agreements will be required from HW vendors
Installation responsibility is with customer

Conclusion:

While TDI/Cloud deployment models are picking up rapidly, it might still take a couple of more years before the appliance model is completely overtaken by TDI/Cloud deployments. Appliance vendors are still investing heavily to build higher capacity appliances. The largest appliance certified by SAP today stands at 20 TB for OLTP systems.

Appliance based installations will continue to exist due to the following customers’ requirements:

Customers with large SAP instances ( Ex: A California based retail giant with 30 TB and 60 TB ECC systems )
Customers in Healthcare or Banking industries that need to meet regulatory requirements
Customers with traditional mindset who are not completely convinced with the security aspects of cloud deployments and/or are concerned about performance

About the Author

Sreedhara Padmanabhuni has 23 years of experience and has been an SAP practitioner for the last 18 years. He is currently based out of New Jersey, USA helping customers in their digital transformation journey in HANA & Cloud space

Service Offerings

Service Offerings

Client Themes

Client Themes

The Future of HANA Appliance

Model with Increasing Adoption

of TDI & Cloud Deployments

About the Author

Service Offerings

Industries

Cloud

Cybersecurity

Digital

EngineeringNXT

Holmes

Contact Us

About Wipro

Careers

Location

Leadership

Investors

Innovation

News and Events

Insights

Analyst speak

Products & Platforms

Partner Ecosystem

Sustainability

Contact Wipro